Showing posts with label corporation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label corporation. Show all posts

Thursday, July 10, 2014

SCOTUS, the corporate veil, & Life

I obviously don't know everything there is to know about this topic, nor is this an exhaustive list of implications surrounding this decision, but here's my two cents for what it's worth:

The recent SCOTUS decision involving Hobby Lobby was brought up for discussion in my master's level business law class this week by the instructor.  He was against the court's decision because of the issue of "piercing the corporate veil."  This perspective really hadn't been discussed much in the news or in any recent discussions I've had concerning this case, so I had to do a little research on it today.  While I understand what the corporate veil is and what it's intended to protect, I can't agree with the second half of a quote from an article I read today: that this decision puts "the interests of businesses over those of individual citizens."  The way I see it, those five men in robes DID protect the interests of individual citizens.  They protected the rights of business owners (individuals) to operate their PRIVATELY held corporations in a manner that doesn't compromise their personal beliefs without forcing their business to pay a very hefty fine for non-compliance with the law.

Whether or not one believes that a business can hold beliefs, we all know that every single business was opened by an individual or group of people who held a common belief about how they wanted to operate the business.  The corporate veil exists to protect the financial interests of the owners or shareholders and to keep them separate from the financial interests of the corporation, and to prevent shady dealings.  BUT, if you think about it, no business can make decisions on its own without a human being behind that decision, because businesses on their own lack the ability to think, right?  Someone, somewhere, is choosing what the business will and will not promote.  It's not a ridiculous idea at all that a corporation is going to naturally take on the beliefs and principles of its owners, which is one of the main arguments for those who are in dissent of this recent SCOTUS decision.  They are arguing that a corporation cannot hold religious beliefs and that the corporate veil has been pierced by allowing the religious beliefs of the owners to penetrate the decisions of the company.

The tremendous financial burden that Hobby Lobby would have born as a result of non-compliance with the ACA requirement to provide insurance-covered abortifacients is a burden that would have been born by the corporation, not by the business owners.  In other words, the corporate veil is still present in this case, in my opinion.  The decision not to provide coverage for abortifacients was still very much a decision of the corporation, even if some conservative Christian person had to be the one to decide that the corporation would refuse to provide that coverage.  What if a business owner didn't believe that providing a matching retirement plan for employees was necessary because they felt it was their employees' job to be responsible with their own money and plan for their own retirement without help?  The business can choose not to provide matching retirement funds!  And people have a choice whether or not they want to work there based on that information.  No one would argue that the corporate veil had been pierced in that situation (probably because it's not a religious belief, but it is a personal belief nonetheless)! 

The bigger issue that I see here (that no one is talking about) is the fact that the ACA's fine for non-compliance is so ridiculously unreasonable!  That size of a fine should be unlawful.  And the fact that there is a mandate that employers pay for abortifacients at all for that matter, is a HUGE issue for me.  I mean really, is it too much to ask men and women to be a teensy bit responsible with their genitals by using preventative means of birth control rather than the "oops I messed up Morning-After Pill?"  Hobby Lobby doesn't think so and neither do I!  Why should an employer be forced to pay for any method of birth control that is not a prescription?  Anyone can get a preventative birth control prescribed to them in this day and age (not that I recommend it, but that's another story for another day). Should a man's employer pay for his non-prescriptive condoms so that he can at least do his part to try not to get a woman pregnant?  If an employer should have to pay for the OTC plan B pill, then I think they ought to be forced to pay for condoms as well.  Oh, and another thing...what makes anyone think it's okay to scream at their employer, "Stay out of my bedroom!" from one side of their mouth but then also demand, "Pay for my birth control!" out of the other side?! It's asinine. 

I believe we've actually sort of run out of things to fight for in this country and we think we can solve all the world's problems, so we've sort of started making up rights to fight for because as humans we will never be content.  Someone always plays devil's advocate, and that's just what they are.  We think we deserve more, we're entitled to more, we're running the show, we're our own creators, and there's no absolute truth.  We refuse to believe that making decisions on our own outside of The Creator's plan actually does cause us harm, illness, pain, and death, and that somehow we can avoid all consequences of our actions by coming up with some new technology or medical means of preventing responsibility for our actions.  Oh, and then force someone else to pay for it as well.  We've tipped the scale so far in one direction we're actually starting to move backward and we don't even see it happening right in front of us. We've gone so far toward promoting "human rights," that we're actually disregarding the fact that in order to have any human rights at all, you first have to be given the right to LIFE.  Do we not see that in order for our species to even continue to exist we have to promote LIFE?!  Not just the wanted or planned life, but all life!  My hat goes off to the owners of Hobby Lobby for staying strong and holding true to what what they think is the most important human right of all: LIFE!

If all unborn babies go to heaven, then the devil's plan has surely backfired (from an eternal perspective).